Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Tallahassee offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Tallahassee’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
Blaze Pizza
9/10 (1633 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 850-536-6325
Customizable pizzasFresh toppingsQuick service
Blaze Pizza offers a unique dining experience where you can customize your pizza with a variety of fresh toppings and watch it being cooked right in front of you. The restaurant is known for its quick service and friendly staff, making it a pleasant place to enjoy a meal. Customers have highlighted the delicious flavor of the pizzas, from the cheesy bread to the carnivore pizza, which is balanced with a sweet balsamic sauce. Although some have mentioned issues with extra cheese, overall, Blaze Pizza is a great option for those looking for a tasty and customizable meal in a clean and friendly environment.
Gaines Street Pies
8.6/10 (1155 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 850-765-9275
Thin crust pizzasLate-night hoursFriendly service
Gaines Street Pies offers a unique pizza experience in Tallahassee that is worth trying out. The thin crust pizzas are a standout feature, with the Bruno and Italian sausage options receiving high praise from customers. The quality of the food matches the service, which is described as both friendly and patient, making for a pleasant dining experience. Additionally, the restaurant’s late hours cater to those looking for a tasty late-night bite. Some customers have noted the occasional consistency issue with their orders, but overall, Gaines Street Pies remains a solid choice for pizza lovers in the area.
Decent Pizza
9/10 (891 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 850-222-6400
Authentic Italian pizzaDelicious garlic knotsExcellent service
Decent Pizza is a must-visit for any pizza enthusiast in Tallahassee. The veg head pizza is unparalleled, and the buffalo chicken pizza is a close second. The warm and welcoming atmosphere, complete with fantastic music, makes for an unforgettable dining experience. The garlic knots are a must-try side dish, and the friendly service ties everything together perfectly. Whether you’re a first-timer or a loyal regular, Decent Pizza is sure to impress!
Momo’s Pizza – Tennessee Street
9/10 (1540 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 850-224-9808
Large slicesFlavorful toppingsFriendly service
Located on Tennessee Street, Momo’s Pizza offers slices so large they can easily rival a personal pizza. The New York-style pizzas are known for their generous sizes and flavorful toppings, with the buffalo chicken slice being a notable standout. Despite the slight greasiness, the pizzas are still flavorful and satisfying. Along with the mouthwatering pizzas, the buffalo cheese sticks are a tasty addition to the menu. The service is friendly, making the dining experience even more enjoyable. If you’re looking for affordable, filling, and delicious pizza in a laid-back atmosphere, Momo’s Pizza is a must-visit spot.
Gaines Street Pies
9/10 (392 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 850-765-4120
Creative flavor pairingsFresh ingredientsUnique Garlic Knots
Gaines Street Pies is a unique pizza spot that goes beyond traditional pies, offering a variety of creative and delicious flavor pairings. The Caprese pizza with fresh Moz was a standout, cooked perfectly and packed with fresh ingredients. The pizzas can be a bit light on toppings, but the flavorful combinations more than make up for it. The Garlic Knots are a must-try, with a milder and more enjoyable garlic flavor compared to other places. The friendly staff and cool comic book-themed interior make for a great dining experience, perfect for both families and pizza enthusiasts alike.
Brickyard Pizzeria
9/10 (588 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 850-562-7425
Huge flavorful pizzasCozy environmentFriendly service
Brickyard Pizzeria offers a truly satisfying pizza experience, with their extensive menu showcasing mouthwatering flavors and quality ingredients. The size of their pizzas alone is impressive, but it’s the perfect balance of crust, sauce, and toppings that make each slice a culinary delight. Whether you’re a pizza enthusiast or simply looking for a delicious meal, Brickyard is a must-visit for those who appreciate both size and flavor in their pizza experience.
Isabella’s Pizzeria Napoletana
9/10 (479 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 850-558-6379
Authentic Neapolitan pizzaHomemade mozzarellaFriendly service
Isabella’s Pizzeria Napoletana in Tallahassee offers a taste of authentic wood-fired Neapolitan pizza that rivals what you’d find in Italy. The Diavola and Margherita pizzas are standouts, with high-quality toppings and a light, tangy tomato sauce that sets them apart. The friendly service and speedy delivery make for a pleasant dining experience, perfect for a casual meal in Collegetown. The homemade mozzarella melts perfectly on each pie, creating a delicious bite that keeps customers coming back for more.
Gaines Street Pies
8.6/10 (515 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 850-329-2141
Quick serviceFlavorful pizzasWarm and welcoming atmosphere
Upon entering Gaines Street Pies, customers are met with a warm and welcoming atmosphere. The service is efficient and friendly, ensuring a quick turnaround for those looking to indulge in a hot and fresh pizza. The variety of options on the menu caters to all tastes, with flavorful pizzas that have a nice texture in the crust. While some dishes may lean on the greasy side, the overall experience is satisfying, making it a solid choice for pizza lovers in search of a good meal. Despite some inconsistencies, Gaines Street Pies delivers on taste and quality, showcasing why it’s a popular spot for those seeking a satisfying pizza experience.
Momo’s Pizza – Market Street
8.8/10 (1472 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 850-412-0222
Wide selection of pizzasAbove-average beer selectionCozy atmosphere
Momo’s Pizza on Market Street is a vibrant pizza shop with a modern kitchen vibe that will surely catch your attention. The selection of pizzas is wide, with fresh ingredients and unique toppings that set them apart. The pizzas are cooked to perfection, boasting a crispy crust and generous portions that will satisfy even the heartiest of appetites. The cozy atmosphere and friendly service make it a great spot to enjoy a meal with friends or family, and the above-average beer selection adds another layer to the dining experience.
Solle’s Pizza
9.4/10 (485 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 850-536-7288
Flavorful toppingsGenerous portionsFriendly staff
Solle’s Pizza offers a unique and delightful pizza experience, with high-quality ingredients that truly make a difference. The pizzas are loaded with flavorful toppings that set them apart from standard pies, resulting in a truly incredible eating experience. The weight of the pizza alone is a testament to the generous portions and hearty flavors that await diners. The friendly staff enhances the dining experience, making you feel welcomed and appreciated throughout your visit. Solle’s Pizza is the perfect spot for those seeking a memorable and satisfying slice that will leave you coming back for more.
Uncle Maddio’s Pizza – Apalachee Parkway
9/10 (704 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 850-765-2875
Crispy pepperoni pizzaSpicy buffalo wingsVariety of fresh toppings
Uncle Maddio’s Pizza – Apalachee Parkway is a must-visit for pizza lovers in the area. The pepperoni pizza is a standout, with a perfect crisp and generous topping of pepperoni that will have you coming back for more. The buffalo wings are also a crowd favorite, delivering a surprising kick of spice that will keep you on your toes. The service is top-notch, with quick and fresh preparation right before your eyes. The vegan pizza is a hidden gem, and the hot and fresh food will leave you satisfied every time. With a wide variety of toppings to choose from, Uncle Maddio’s is sure to become a go-to spot for pizza enthusiasts everywhere.
Village Pizza & Pasta
8.6/10 (545 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 850-893-9001
Fresh pizzaExcellent serviceFlavorful rolls
Village Pizza & Pasta offers a pizza experience that is fresh, flavorful, and satisfying. The extra cheese on the pizza and the deliciously light sauce truly stand out, making each bite a delightful experience. The pepperonis add an extra layer of flavor that adds to the overall taste. Despite some negative reviews, the quality of the food remains consistent and worthy of a visit. The service is impeccable, with attentive and friendly staff ensuring a pleasant dining experience. The restaurant may have its ups and downs, but for those seeking a simple yet delicious pizza, Village Pizza & Pasta is a reliable choice.
Uncle Maddio’s Pizza – Mahan
9/10 (839 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 850-765-1681
Customizable pizzasFresh, quality ingredientsCasual, fast service
Uncle Maddio’s Pizza – Mahan offers a unique ordering experience akin to Subway, allowing customers to customize their pizzas with fresh ingredients and vegan options. The friendly and patient staff create the pizzas quickly, ensuring a fast service. The variety of toppings are endless, and the quality of the ingredients shines through in each bite. The concept of a DIY pizza bar paired with a casual, outdoor seating option makes this spot ideal for a quick bite, family dinner, or student hangout. The menu also includes alcohol choices, adding to the relaxed vibe of the restaurant. The inviting atmosphere and delicious pizzas make Uncle Maddio’s a must-visit spot in the area.
Munchies Pizza
8.8/10 (341 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 850-759-0660
Generous toppingsValue for moneyFriendly staff
Munchies Pizza offers a mouthwatering array of pizza options, from deep dish Chicago style to hand-tossed classics. The generous toppings and cheese-stuffed crust of the deep dish are a highlight, along with the aromatic and flavorful sauce that sets it apart. The value for money is exceptional, with portions large enough to leave leftovers even for hearty eaters. The friendly staff ensures a pleasant dining experience, with quick service and helpful recommendations for those new to the menu. The cozy and inviting atmosphere, complete with arcade games, adds to the overall charm of this pizza joint. Whether you’re a deep-dish aficionado or a traditional pizza lover, Munchies Pizza is definitely worth a visit.
Coach’s Pizza
9/10 (220 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 850-895-9337
Cozy atmosphereDelicious deep dishFantastic customer service
Coach’s Pizza brings a cozy, welcoming atmosphere with delicious deep dish pizza that is a hidden gem in the pizza scene. The crust is perfect, cheese generously stuffed with meat, and the sauce is outstanding. The 8-inch deep dish feeds 2-3 people and is wholesome and filling, making it a must-try on their menu.
Five Star Pizza
9/10 (459 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 850-361-3661
Various SizesDelicious AromaDirect Delivery
Five Star Pizza in Tallahassee has become a beloved favorite among locals for its consistently delicious pies and excellent customer service. Customers rave about the various sizes available, with many eager to try the largest option next time. The aroma of the pizza as you bring it to your car is simply mouthwatering, while the quality of the thin crust and regular crust options is consistently praised. With delivery available directly from the restaurant, it’s no surprise that Five Star Pizza has yet to disappoint its loyal patrons.
Momo’s Pizza – Pensacola Street
9/10 (464 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 850-900-5784
Unique charcuterie pizzaLarge slicesTop-notch service
Momo’s Pizza – Pensacola Street in Tallahassee has quickly become a favorite among locals and visitors alike. The charcuterie board pizza is a standout, offering a unique and delicious twist on traditional pizza flavors. The atmosphere is welcoming and the staff are attentive, making for a pleasant dining experience. The large slices are perfect for sharing or enjoying as a meal on their own, and the side salads are a pleasant surprise, offering a fresh and satisfying option. The menu has a good variety of Italian favorites, and the service is top-notch, ensuring a memorable visit every time.
Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza
9/10 (222 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 850-270-3636
Unique pizza optionsExceptional customer serviceCozy atmosphere
Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza has quickly become a favorite among locals and visitors alike. The lunch specials are a hit, with delicious options like meatball apps and personal pizzas. The food is top-notch, with standout items like the rolls served with Italian dressing and unique pizzas like the Buffalo Chicken and Meat Eater. The staff here truly goes above and beyond, providing exceptional service without rushing customers. The atmosphere is welcoming, making it the perfect spot for a family outing or date night. Whether it’s the attentive service, flavorful food, or inviting ambiance, Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza is a must-visit for any Italian cuisine lover.
Tour of Italy
9.2/10 (792 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 850-727-8794
Generous PortionsTasty DishesAttentive Service
Tour of Italy stands out for its generous portions and tasty dishes, with standout items like the lasagna and garlic knots impressing customers. The restaurant’s cozy ambiance and attentive service also add to the dining experience, making it a must-try Italian spot in the area. The dessert options, especially the tiramisu, are also highly recommended for a sweet finish to your meal. However, some customers mention the need for lighter sauce options and improvements in flavor profiles for certain dishes. Overall, Tour of Italy is worth a visit for its hearty Italian fare and friendly staff.
Red Elephant Pizza & Grill
8.6/10 (777 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 850-668-7492
Family-friendly serviceDelicious, fresh foodAffordable prices
Red Elephant Pizza & Grill is a family-friendly spot that truly shines in its service. The servers go above and beyond to ensure a pleasant dining experience, especially for families with kids. The staff is attentive, engaging with young diners and making them feel special. The food is also noteworthy, with a variety of options that are hot, fresh, and delicious. The menu has something for everyone, and the prices are affordable, making it a great value for the whole family.