Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Toledo offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Toledo’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
PizzaPapalis
8.8/10 (1935 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 419-244-7722
Authentic tavern-style pizzaSavory deep dishExcellent customer service
Nestled in Toledo is a hidden gem that offers authentic tavern-style pizza reminiscent of Chicago’s Lou Malnati’s. PizzaPapalis puts out a mouthwatering deep dish oozing with savory toppings and a buttery crust that has diners raving. Despite minor glitches like charging for garlic powder and a mix-up with thin crust versus deep dish, the flavors are top-notch. The meatball appetizer covered in cheese and marinara is a crowd favorite, and the seafood pizza, though lacking, still has its charm. The service shines here, with friendly staff who go out of their way to accommodate large groups and make diners feel at home. If you’re in the mood for a decadent pizza feast, PizzaPapalis is the place to be.
Home Slice Pizza
9/10 (1534 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 419-724-7437
Cozy atmosphereDelicious pizzaFriendly service
Home Slice Pizza offers a unique dining experience with its two stories and charming patios, making it a perfect spot for a casual meal with friends and family. The decor, including rustic walls, adds to the cozy ambiance of the restaurant. The menu features delicious options like chicken wings, pizza, and sandwiches, all prepared with care and served promptly by friendly staff. Whether you’re a regular patron or a first-time visitor, Home Slice Pizza’s tasty offerings and inviting atmosphere are sure to leave you satisfied and eager to return.
Jo-Jo’s Original Pizzeria
8.6/10 (849 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 419-473-1223
Thin crust pizzaGenerous pasta portionsCozy atmosphere
Nestled in Toledo, Jo-Jo’s Original Pizzeria offers a unique dining experience with multiple areas for guests to enjoy, from a dining room to a game room. The decor is modest yet inviting, creating a cozy atmosphere to savor their delicious offerings. The standout here is the thin crust pizza, which customers rave about. Pair it with a hearty pasta dish, generously sauced, for a satisfying meal. The attentive and friendly staff add to the overall enjoyable dining experience at Jo-Jo’s.
Pizza Cat
9/10 (1337 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 419-214-1640
Tasty vegan optionsPerfectly cooked crustDelicious sauce
Pizza Cat truly stands out for their tasty vegan options. The crust is cooked to perfection and the sauce is delicious. While some may find the pizza a bit pricy for the size, the flavors and quality definitely make up for it. The restaurant’s dedication to providing vegan options that are flavorful and satisfying is commendable, making it a must-try for plant-based pizza lovers.
The Stubborn Brother Pizza Bar
8.6/10 (1219 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 419-720-1818
Thin, crispy crustFlavorful toppingsModern atmosphere
When you step into The Stubborn Brother Pizza Bar, you’ll immediately notice the modern and open atmosphere. The view of the bar and the kitchen adds to the experience. The specialty pizzas are the stars of the show here, with a thin and crispy crust that takes you right to the streets of NYC. The quality sauce and fresh toppings truly elevate the flavors, making each bite a delightful experience. And don’t forget to try the white pizza, which has customers raving with its phenomenal taste. Whether you’re looking for a casual slice or a customized pie, this pizza joint is worth a visit.
Blaze Pizza
9.2/10 (1238 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 419-463-9274
Exceptional serviceCustomizable optionsFresh ingredients
Blaze Pizza sets itself apart from other pizza joints with its exceptional service and attention to detail. The staff goes above and beyond to accommodate special dietary needs, such as dairy allergies, ensuring a safe and enjoyable dining experience for all customers. The quick and efficient service combined with fresh ingredients and customizable options make for a truly satisfying meal. Whether you’re a pizza aficionado or simply looking for a tasty and convenient dining option, Blaze Pizza delivers on all fronts.
Original Gino’s Pizza
8.6/10 (1645 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 419-472-3567
Crispy-chewy crustGenerously topped pizzasButtery cheesebread
Original Gino’s Pizza is a beloved establishment that has gained a loyal following for its delicious offerings. The regular crust strikes the perfect balance between crispy and chewy, and the pizzas are generously topped with fresh ingredients. Customers rave about the friendly and polite staff, ensuring that each order is inspected and prepared with care. The cheesebread is a standout menu item, with its buttery, garlicky goodness and light, airy dough. While the dining area may be closed, the quality of the pizza remains top-notch for takeout orders. Original Gino’s Pizza is definitely worth a visit for some of the best Chicago sausage pizza in the area.
Amie’s Pizza Factory
9/10 (471 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 419-842-8008
Award-winning pizzaSweet sauceVariety of options
Amie’s Pizza Factory serves up award-winning pizza that delights the taste buds with toppings that reach the edge, a fantastic sauce, and perfectly cooked dough. While the prices may be a bit on the higher side, the quality of the pizza more than makes up for it. The variety of specialty pizzas and other menu options make this a great spot to satisfy your pizza cravings, and the sweet sauce adds a unique and delicious twist. Don’t miss out on the delicious creations waiting for you at Amie’s Pizza Factory.
Half Time Pizza – Toledo, OH
8.8/10 (262 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 419-517-2190
Homemade sauceAbundant toppingsWelcoming atmosphere
Located in Toledo, OH, Half Time Pizza is a local gem that serves up delicious pies that are a delightful balance between thick and thin crust. The homemade sauce gives their pizzas a unique flavor that sets them apart from the competition. Toppings are abundant and of high quality, ensuring a satisfying dining experience. The friendly service and welcoming atmosphere add to the appeal of this hidden gem, making it a must-visit for pizza lovers in the area.
Inky’s Italian Foods
9/10 (1669 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 419-476-0500
Old-school atmosphereDelicious cheese breadMemorable lasagna
As a food journalist, I can confidently say that Inky’s Italian Foods offers a unique dining experience with its old-school atmosphere and delicious Italian classics. The cheese bread and marinara sauce are standout appetizers, setting the stage for a memorable meal. The lasagna is a true highlight, covered in a decadent sauce and gooey cheese. While some may find the red sauce a bit overpowering, it’s clear that the kitchen takes pride in using quality ingredients. The personalized service and reasonable prices make Inky’s a must-visit for those craving a taste of authentic Italian cuisine with a touch of nostalgia.
Salute! Pizzeria
8.8/10 (188 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 419-407-5516
Delicious pizzaTraditional crustFriendly service
Salute! Pizzeria offers a variety of delicious pizza options that are well-prepared and mouthwateringly good. The traditional crust is superb, providing a satisfying experience with each bite. Despite the simple decor, the focus here is definitely on the pizza, which consistently impresses customers. Friendly service is a constant at Salute! making it a highly recommended spot for a satisfying meal.
Jack Demsey’s
8.6/10 (1369 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-629-9899
Great beer selectionGenerous food portionsTraditional Irish ambiance
Jack Demsey’s is a delightful spot to enjoy good food and drinks. The menu boasts tasty options like wings and shepherds pie, all served in a warm and iconic Irish ambiance. The portions are generous, and the staff is attentive, creating a welcoming atmosphere for a casual meal or a quick stop for a refreshing beer. Whether you’re looking for a great pint of Guinness or delicious bar food, Jack Demsey’s is a solid choice for a satisfying dining experience.
Hindsight Pizza Kitchen
9/10 (76 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 419-472-3663
Unique specialty pizzasConvenient online orderingDelicious Sweet Style sauce
Hindsight Pizza Kitchen has quickly become a favorite among many customers, with its delicious and unique specialty pizzas like the Korean chicken and Loaded Potato. The online ordering system is convenient and user-friendly, making it easy for customers to get their hands on these mouthwatering pies. The Sweet Style sauce has been a hit, described as absolutely delicious and not overly sugary. The attentive staff and excellent customer service only add to the overall experience of dining at Hindsight Pizza Kitchen.
Keith and Chris Incorvaia’s Bene Italiano restaurant
8.8/10 (660 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 419-407-5776
Generous portionsAuthentic flavorsImpeccable service
Bene Italiano restaurant promises a culinary experience that will leave you craving more. The portions are generous, the flavors authentically Italian, and the service impeccable. From the seasoned fries to the award-worthy cannoli, every bite is a delight. You’ll find yourself reminiscing about your nonna’s cooking as you savor dishes like the chicken alfredo, artichoke pizza, and homemade ravioli.
Jet’s Pizza
8.8/10 (228 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 419-841-7700
Detroit style pizzaCheesy breadsticksHomemade ranch dressing
Jet’s Pizza offers a unique Detroit style pizza that is a hit among customers. The crust is thick, crunchy on the outside, fluffy on the inside, and perfectly cooked. The variety of crust options allows for customization, and the flavorful toppings and sauces truly enhance the overall taste. Customers also rave about the cheesy breadsticks, which are fresh and delicious. Additionally, Jet’s Pizza is known for its homemade ranch dressing that is available for purchase in bottles. The friendly staff, quick service, and generous portions make Jet’s Pizza a standout choice for pizza lovers.
Vito’s Pizza and Subs UT, Westgate and Ottawa Hills
8.8/10 (261 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 419-537-1000
Diverse menu optionsAttentive serviceConsistent quality
Nestled in Toledo, Vito’s Pizza and Subs UT, Westgate and Ottawa Hills is a local gem that has captured the hearts of many with their mouth-watering pizzas and delectable Italian fold-over subs. Customers can’t stop raving about the diverse menu options, attentive service, and consistent quality of the food. Whether it’s the flavorful chicken chipotle pizza or the cheesy cheese bread, Vito’s offers a little something for everyone. The staff goes above and beyond to ensure that each order is prepared with care and ready on time, making every visit a satisfying experience. With Vito’s, you don’t just get a meal – you get a taste of true Toledo hospitality.
Jet’s Pizza
8.6/10 (376 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 419-381-6700
Thick, crispy crustConsistent tasteEfficient staff
Jet’s Pizza offers a solid pizza option, with rave reviews on their thick, crispy crust and consistency in taste. Customers have noted the convenience of ordering online and the free Detroit Deep Dish style pizza offered as a welcome coupon. While some have experienced delivery mishaps and pricing concerns, others have praised the staff for their efficiency and friendly service. The gluten-free pizza has also received positive feedback for its quality. Overall, Jet’s Pizza seems to be a spot worth returning to for a filling and satisfying pizza option.
Gino’s Italian Delites
9.2/10 (230 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 419-389-1500
Unique flavor profileWarm hospitalityLocal favorite
Nestled in the heart of the community, Gino’s Italian Delites is a beloved spot for pizza aficionados. The crust, though not always perfect, offers a satisfying chew, while the sauce delivers a unique flavor profile that keeps customers coming back for more. The owners’ warm hospitality shines through in every visit, making it a top pick for families and pizza lovers alike. Though there may be occasional missteps, the overall experience at this Eastgate location is one that should not be missed.
Mazzas stone baked pizza co.
9.6/10 (215 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 419-720-9394
Outstanding foodExceptional customer serviceVariety beyond pizza
Mazza’s stone baked pizza co. is a true hidden gem that delivers outstanding food and exceptional customer service. The pizza is top-notch, especially the Detroit style and supreme handtossed options, which have left customers raving about the quality and value. The variety on the menu extends beyond just pizza, with options like Fettuccine Alfredo and chicken parm that have also received high praise. The friendly staff and reasonable prices make this a must-try spot for anyone looking for a delicious meal that won’t break the bank. The overall experience at Mazza’s is sure to have you coming back for more.
Jomaa Brothers Pizza
8.8/10 (187 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 419-255-4235
Cheesy pullsPretzel crustFriendly service
Jomaa Brothers Pizza in Toledo is a standout in the crowded pizza scene. Customers rave about the fantastic cheesy pulls on their pies, with one even comparing it to a scene from a goofy movie. The pretzel-like crust adds a unique twist to their delicious creations, making it a must-try for pizza lovers. The staff is always friendly and accommodating, with a long history of providing top-notch service dating back to 1999. Despite the occasional hiccup, like forgetting banana peppers on a garden pizza, the team at Jomaa Brothers consistently delivers amazing food and exceptional customer care.