Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Tyler offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Tyler’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
Top It Off Pizza
9.2/10 (377 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 903-630-5524
Authentic flavorsPersonalized serviceHomemade cannolis
Top It Off Pizza is a hidden gem that delivers a taste of authentic and delicious pizza that will transport you back home, no matter where that may be. The Alfredo Supreme pizza is cooked to perfection and bursting with flavor, making it a must-try. The owner’s welcoming nature and personal touch add to the overall charm of the place, making every visit a delightful experience. From the mouthwatering pizza to the homemade cannolis, Top It Off Pizza is a true standout in the pizza scene.
New York Pizza & Pasta
9/10 (951 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 903-504-5234
Authentic flavorsExceptional serviceCrispy pizza crust
New York Pizza & Pasta is a gem that truly captures the essence of authentic New York-style pizza. The fresh ingredients shine in every bite, with the perfect balance of sauce, cheese, and toppings. The meatball sub draped in fresh mozzarella is a must-try, while the staff’s exceptional service elevates the experience. You’ll find yourself savoring every morsel of their mouthwatering dishes, from the savory lasagna to the crispy wings. This spot truly stands out as a top contender in the Tyler area for those craving a taste of New York right at home.
Bruno’s | Pizza & Pasta
9/10 (1257 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 903-939-0002
Inviting atmosphereDelicious foodGenerous servings
Located in Tyler, Bruno’s | Pizza & Pasta is a beloved Italian eatery that has been a community staple since the early 70s. The atmosphere is inviting, the food is delicious, and the serving sizes are generous. The menu offers a fantastic mix of pizza, pasta, sandwiches, and salads, with standout items like the muffaletta. The building is clean, neat, and trendy, providing a comfortable dining experience. The service is attentive, with staff members who are described as delightful. Whether you’re a longtime fan or a first-time visitor, Bruno’s is a must-try for Italian cuisine lovers.
Topp’s Pizza
9.4/10 (565 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 903-258-6111
Half and half pizzaGenerous toppingsBacon cheddar fries
The innovative half and half pizza is a standout at Topp’s Pizza, allowing indecisive customers to enjoy two different flavors in one. The crust is perfectly thin on this unique pie, catering to those who prefer a lighter base. Topp’s Pizza doesn’t hold back on toppings, ensuring each slice is generously covered and bursting with flavor.
Rotolo’s Pizzeria
9/10 (939 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 903-561-8805
Thin, crisp crustFlavorful meatballsEfficient ordering process
Rotolo’s Pizzeria offers a refreshing pizza experience with a variety of delicious options that won’t leave you feeling heavy or greasy. The crust is thin and crisp, the sauce is flavorful without being overpowering, and the toppings are fresh. The spaghetti with Tre Meatballs is a standout dish, with incredibly flavorful meatballs that are worth ordering on their own. The Chicken Alfredo pizza is a great option for those who typically struggle with tomato sauce, as it is light and easy to digest. The ordering process is simple and efficient, with friendly staff ready to assist. Rotolo’s Pizzeria is a must-visit in Tyler, TX for a satisfying and tasty meal.
Marco’s Pizza
8.6/10 (384 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 903-561-5550
Fresh and hot pizzaFriendly and helpful staffTop-notch quality and taste
Marco’s Pizza is known for its fresh and hot pizza, with the staff being extremely friendly and helpful. The quality and taste of the pizza is top-notch, with customers also praising the unique option of cheddar cheese. Although some received the wrong order or experienced issues with delivery, the overall consensus is that the food is delicious and worth a visit. The welcoming atmosphere and hardworking employees, like Sal and Nathaniel, contribute to a positive dining experience, making Marco’s a reliable go-to spot for flavorful pizzas and great service.
Little Italy Restaurant
8.6/10 (1195 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 903-595-1184
Welcoming atmosphereDelicious homemade cuisineAttentive and warm service
Little Italy Restaurant is a hidden gem that welcomes guests with open arms, creating a charming and comforting atmosphere that feels like a home away from home. The staff’s warm and attentive service ensures a delightful dining experience, with knowledgeable recommendations and prompt service that make you feel like part of the family. The menu boasts delicious homemade Italian cuisine, with generous portions and flavorful dishes like chicken parmigiano and creamy shrimp Alfredo. While the noise level can rise when the restaurant gets busy, the overall experience at Little Italy Restaurant is sure to leave you satisfied and eagerly planning your next visit.
Roma Italian Kitchen & Bar
9/10 (355 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 903-630-3011
Delicious fresh foodExcellent serviceCozy atmosphere
Roma Italian Kitchen & Bar is a hidden gem in Tyler, Texas that offers high-quality food and excellent service. The restaurant may be off the beaten path, but it is worth the visit for the delicious and fresh dishes they serve. From the spinach ravioli with Alfredo sauce to the tiramisu with a Kahlua shot, every item on the menu is made with care and attention to detail. The breadsticks and dipping oil/herbs are a must-try, and the cozy atmosphere with piano music in the background adds to the dining experience. If you’re looking for authentic Italian cuisine in a peaceful setting, Roma Italian Kitchen & Bar is the place to be.
Pizza Hut
8.6/10 (80 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 903-707-8205
ConsistencyQualityDedication
Pizza Hut, anchored by manager Mrs. Cathy Taylor, stands out among the rest for its consistency and high-quality ingredients. The pizzas are indeed delicious, but what truly sets this location apart is the dedication of its staff members. The commitment to excellence is palpable with every order, making Hwy 64 and 7925 S Broadway the top choices in town for a satisfying pizza experience.
Pizza Hut
8.8/10 (72 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 430-247-0099
Exceptional serviceConsistent, delicious pizzasPride in brand representation
Pizza Hut truly stands out for their exceptional service and dedication to their customers. The positive attitudes and willingness to go above and beyond are evident in every interaction, making for a truly enjoyable experience. With a focus on presenting a well-maintained store and representing the brand with pride, you can always count on consistent, delicious pizzas and top-notch service. Wes set the bar high with his polite and helpful customer service, making it clear that this location truly values their patrons.
Villaggio del Vino
8.8/10 (353 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 903-534-8466
Exceptional wood-fired pizzaTop-notch serviceCozy and inviting atmosphere
Nestled in the heart of the city, Villaggio del Vino is a hidden gem that promises to delight your taste buds. The food is exceptional, with standout dishes like Italian meatballs, spinach and cheese ravioli, and double pepperoni pizza that will leave you feeling full and satisfied. The wood-fired pizza is a definite highlight, boasting a crust that is one of the best in town. The service is top-notch, with friendly and attentive staff like Alena who go above and beyond to ensure you have a memorable dining experience. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, perfect for a casual dinner or a special celebration. Villaggio del Vino is a must-visit for food lovers looking for delicious Italian cuisine in a charming setting.
Bubba’s 33
9/10 (725 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 430-288-5200
Varied menuFlavorful foodVibrant atmosphere
Bubba’s 33 is a lively spot that delivers a dynamic dining experience for families and friends alike. The menu is extensive, offering crowd-pleasing options like the classic burger with Bubbas sauce and a variety of tasty pizzas. The food is flavorful, satisfying even the pickiest eaters. The atmosphere is vibrant and high-energy, making it the perfect place to catch a game or enjoy a casual date night. The service is on point, with attentive servers and waitstaff making sure every customer has a great experience. Bubba’s 33 truly hits the mark when it comes to great food, good service, and a fun atmosphere.
Mario’s Italian Restaurant
9.2/10 (565 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 903-581-2309
Classic vibesHouse-made breadGenerous portion sizes
Nestled in Tyler, Mario’s Italian Restaurant offers an unparalleled dining experience with classic vibes and live entertainment. The house-made bread is a standout, baked to perfection, and the linguini primavera is fresh and delicious. The cozy atmosphere and attentive staff make for a memorable meal, with dishes prepared with love and care. The portion sizes are generous, and the creamy Italian cake is a delightful sweet treat to end the meal. Mario’s is not just a place to eat, but an unforgettable experience that captures the essence of authentic Italian dining.
Oliveto Italian Bistro
8.6/10 (1027 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 903-581-2678
Unique dishesMouthwatering meatballsExcellent service
Oliveto Italian Bistro offers an array of unique dishes that leave customers wanting more. From the savory pepperoni bread paired with two sauces to the mouthwatering meatballs that are sure to impress, every dish is full of flavor and made with fresh ingredients. The Fire Roasted Pizza is a standout, with a light and crispy crust that elevates the taste to a whole new level. The staff, like Mariela and Whitney, provide excellent service, making for a pleasant dining experience. The gluten-free options are a rare find and are equally delicious. While the bathrooms may need some attention, the overall atmosphere and food quality at Oliveto Italian Bistro make it a must-visit for any food lover.
Piada Italian Street Food
9.2/10 (761 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 903-266-9120
Build-your-own conceptGenerous portionsEngaging and polite staff
Piada Italian Street Food at Cumberland Mall offers a build-your-own concept with Italian bowls, burritos, salads, and pastas. The freshness and flavor are highlighted, making it a must-try spot. The portions are generous, and the Avocado Chopped salad with creamy Parmesan dressing is a standout choice. While the menu may be small, the quality of the food is great, making Piada a frequent favorite for many patrons. The staff, led by manager Luis, is engaging, polite, and eager to ensure a positive dining experience. The establishment is clean and organized, creating a welcoming atmosphere for guests. The service has shown improvement, with recent efforts to address any issues and go above and beyond for customers. Piada Italian Street Food delivers on both taste and customer service, making it a top choice for Italian street food lovers.
Bella Italian Cafe Restaurant
9.2/10 (445 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 903-581-2389
Impeccable serviceAuthentic Italian cuisineDelicious, homemade tiramisu
Bella Italian Cafe Restaurant is a true hidden gem that offers impeccable service and delicious, authentic Italian cuisine. From the perfectly prepared veal to the homemade tiramisu, every dish is a delight. The pasta combo is a must-try, with five different pastas and plenty of flavorful sauce. The pizza is a standout, with options like the margherita available upon request. Bella Italian Cafe Restaurant is a must-visit for anyone craving quality Italian food in a welcoming atmosphere.