Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style fold or a gourmet Neapolitan masterpiece, Wilmington offers a selection of pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
From crispy thin crusts adorned with local produce to hearty deep-dish wonders that ooze with molten cheese, Wilmington’s pizza scene offers something to satiate every palate. This guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of culinary heaven.
Your Pie Pizza
9/10 (837 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 910-399-2848
Fresh, thin-crust pizzaVariety of keto-friendly, gluten-free optionsExceptional customer service
Your Pie Pizza is a must-visit gem for fresh, thin-crust pizza lovers. Not only do they offer a variety of keto-friendly and gluten-free options, but they also provide top-notch service. The staff is friendly and goes above and beyond to ensure customer satisfaction. The hand-stretched pizzas are cooked to perfection and can be customized to your liking. With additional offerings like gelato, fresh salads, and pasta, Your Pie Pizza truly stands out as a unique and delightful dining experience. The environment is clean and up-to-date, and the quick service adds to the overall positive experience. While there may be slight inconsistencies in pizza sizes, the dedication to quality and customer care more than make up for it. Give Your Pie Pizza a try and build your own delicious pizza without any hidden charges.
Slice of Life Pizzeria & Pub Beach
8.8/10 (725 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 910-256-2229
Beachfront locationPizza by the sliceVegan options
Located right on the beach, Slice of Life Pizzeria & Pub Beach offers a unique dining experience with delicious food and a laid-back atmosphere. The pizza options are diverse and cater to both meat lovers and vegetarians, with vegan cheese available as well. The ability to order pizza by the slice is a convenient option for those wanting to try a variety of flavors. The staff at this location provide exceptional service, making sure to check on customers regularly and ensuring a pleasant dining experience. Whether you’re a local looking for a neighborhood hangout or a visitor on vacation, Slice of Life Pizzeria & Pub Beach is the perfect spot to enjoy good food and good company.
Cugino Forno Wilmington
9.8/10 (734 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 910-399-1536
Perfectly chewy doughFresh, high-quality toppingsOutstanding service
Nestled in the heart of Wilmington, Cugino Forno offers a unique and authentic pizza experience that is sure to please even the most discerning palate. The perfectly chewy and crispy pizza dough sets the stage for a delicious array of toppings, all of which are fresh and high-quality. Not only does Cugino Forno excel in crafting delectable pizzas, but the gelato displayed in a spinning refrigerated case adds an extra touch of charm to the dining experience. The staff goes above and beyond to ensure every guest feels welcome and valued, with outstanding service that truly sets this establishment apart. With a fun location that caters to families and a dedicated owner like Emir, Cugino Forno is a must-visit destination for those seeking a memorable culinary adventure.
Mellow Mushroom Wilmington
9/10 (1760 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 910-452-3773
Unique PizzasFriendly StaffFun Atmosphere
Mellow Mushroom Wilmington in the downtown historical district offers a unique experience with their unconventional pizzas like the Thai Dye and Merry Prankster. The crust, undeniably good, provides the perfect canvas for the bursting flavors of the toppings. While some customers might have experienced slight disappointments with the portions, the friendly staff and amazing vibe make up for it. The food is plentiful, incredible, and reasonably priced, making it a must-visit for pizza lovers in the area.
Pie’s On Pizzeria & Grill
9.4/10 (186 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 910-769-2011
Authentic New York pizza$25 wings on WednesdaysGenerous portions
Nestled in the heart of the city, Pie’s On Pizzeria & Grill has quickly earned a loyal following for its authentic New York style pizza. The thin crust strikes the perfect balance of crispiness, the sauce is not overpowering, and the generous toppings are cooked to perfection with a hint of char on the edges. But the real standout here is the $.25 wings available on Wednesdays – an unbeatable deal that keeps customers coming back for more. Despite some missteps with service, the hardworking staff and delicious food make Pie’s On Pizzeria & Grill a must-visit spot for pizza lovers.
I Love NY Pizza
9.2/10 (1058 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 910-762-7628
Authentic NY-styleQuality ingredientsEfficient service
I Love NY Pizza in Wilmington, NC is a must-visit spot for pizza lovers. The thin crust is reminiscent of authentic New York-style slices, with just the right amount of crunch. The variety of choices, including ordering by the slice, makes it easy to try different combinations. The quality of the ingredients really shines through, from the delicious sauce to the flavorful toppings. The service is efficient and friendly, adding to the overall positive experience of grabbing a slice at this carry-out only establishment. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, don’t miss out on this slice of pizza heaven.
Slice of Life Pizzeria & Pub Downtown
8.6/10 (1641 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 910-251-9444
Thin, crispy crustFresh toppingsDog-friendly outdoor seating
Slice of Life Pizzeria & Pub Downtown is a solid choice for a quick, satisfying meal in Wilmington. The thin, crispy crust of their pizza makes for a delightful bite, especially when paired with their fresh toppings that are a cut above the rest. The outdoor seating, complete with dog-friendly fenced-in area, adds a cozy touch to the dining experience. The variety of choices on the menu, from pizza to pasta salad, ensures there is something for everyone. The attentive staff, although a bit busy at times, adds to the overall enjoyable dining experience.
Italian Bistro – Porters Neck
9/10 (654 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 910-686-7774
Traditional Italian dishesAttentive and enthusiastic serviceFresh and flavorful ingredients
Italian Bistro – Porters Neck in Wilmington, NC offers a delightful dining experience. The cozy atmosphere makes it perfect for a casual lunch or dinner. The flavors of the traditional Italian dishes really shine here, from the al dente pasta to the flavorful soup and meatballs. The menu has some interesting options like the chicken pesto sandwich, perfect for those feeling adventurous. The attentive and enthusiastic service really adds to the charm of this small hole-in-the-wall spot. The Stromboli, made to order with fresh ingredients, is a must-try and worth every penny.
Brooklyn Pizza Co.
9/10 (926 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 910-395-5558
Authentic NY pizzaDelicious lasagnaCozy pizzeria setting
Brooklyn Pizza Co. in Wilmington offers a taste of authentic New York pizza right in North Carolina. The lasagna, calzone, wings, and sausage pizza are standout menu items, with the lasagna rivaling that of more upscale establishments in the area. The wings are generously sized, and the honey BBQ sauce is flavorful. When dining in, the atmosphere is reminiscent of a classic New York pizza joint. While some reviewers have had issues with greasy pepperoni pizzas, overall, Brooklyn Pizza Co. is a must-try for both locals and visitors.
Agostino’s Pizza & Pasta
9.2/10 (631 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 910-769-1282
Affordable pricesDelicious flat sausageOutstanding Chicken Bacon Ranch slice
Agostino’s Pizza & Pasta is a hidden gem serving up delicious food at affordable prices. The Sausage slice with flat sausage is a standout, and the Buffalo chicken roll, though not on the menu, is a must-try. The Chicken Bacon Ranch slice is outstanding and leaves a lasting impression. The friendly staff and clean facilities only add to the overall positive experience at this restaurant.
Antonio’s Pizza & Pasta
8.6/10 (768 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 910-792-0000
Welcoming staffDelicious Chicken ParmesanFamily-friendly atmosphere
Antonio’s Pizza & Pasta is known for its family-friendly atmosphere and delicious food offerings. The restaurant’s attentive and welcoming staff ensure a pleasant dining experience, making it a favorite spot for many customers. The Chicken Parmesan, garlic bread with mozzarella cheese, and chicken tenders are highly recommended dishes that keep patrons coming back. With a focus on customer satisfaction, Antonio’s shines in providing a top-notch dining experience, complete with tasty Italian cuisine and a welcoming environment.
Mellow Mushroom Wilmington – Downtown
8.8/10 (269 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 910-769-6688
Unique decorDelicious vegan optionsStunning outdoor seating
Mellow Mushroom Wilmington – Downtown offers a unique and artistic decor that adds to its cool and laid-back vibe, making it a great spot for families. The wide selection of pizzas, including delicious vegan options like the “Miss Mushroom”, are a standout here. The food is not only tasty but is also served promptly, ensuring a great dining experience. Additionally, the outdoor seating area provides stunning views and enhances the overall ambiance of the restaurant.
Vito’s Midtown Pizza
8.6/10 (195 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 910-338-2050
NYC-style crustFlavorful toppingsQuality ingredients
Vito’s Midtown Pizza in Wilmington is a must-visit spot for pizza lovers. Their pies are reminiscent of NYC style pizza, with perfectly baked thin crusts that can be folded in half. The flavors are on point, from the savory cheese bread to the hearty toppings on their pizzas. The white pizza with fluffy ricotta cheese and olive oil baked into the crust is a standout, transporting you back to Italy with each bite. Vito’s attention to detail and quality ingredients truly shine, making it a go-to pizza place in the area.
Salita Pizza
9.2/10 (66 reviews)
Delicious flavor profilesHigh-quality, seasonal ingredientsFriendly and knowledgeable staff
Salita Pizza in Wilmington’s Cargo District is known for its delicious flavor profiles and high-quality, seasonal ingredients. The Burrata pizza stands out for its explosion of flavors, while the Bagels and Ice Cream are also highly recommended. Customers praise the thought and care put into the food preparation, making it a favorite spot in town. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable, making the dining experience even more enjoyable.
Slice of Life Pizzeria & Pub Pine Valley
8.6/10 (685 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 910-799-1399
Amazing pizzaFriendly staffInviting atmosphere
Nestled in Pine Valley, Slice of Life Pizzeria & Pub offers a delightful dining experience that keeps patrons coming back. The pizza here is nothing short of outstanding – from the savory sauce to the perfect blend of spices, each slice is a culinary masterpiece worth savoring. The staff at this pizzeria truly shines, with their warm welcoming smiles and impeccable service making every visit a pleasure. The atmosphere is inviting, with ample seating options and a cozy ambiance perfect for enjoying a meal. While prices may be slightly high, the quality of the food and the exceptional service make it all worthwhile.
Brooklyn Pizza Co.
9/10 (128 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 910-218-3988
Authentic NYC pizzaFresh ingredientsReasonable prices
Brooklyn Pizza Co. is a beloved spot for many locals and even those willing to travel quite a distance for a taste of their New York-style pizza. The Grandma slice is a standout favorite, and the sheer size of the pizza means it can easily feed a large family. Customers rave about the fresh ingredients and amazing taste that make every bite a delight. Whether you’re into calzones, garlic bread, wings, or bruschetta, the menu has something for everyone. Despite a few negative experiences, Brooklyn Pizza Co. remains a go-to spot for those craving authentic NYC pizza with a hint of southern flair.
Jay’s Incredible Pizza
8.8/10 (120 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 910-791-7080
Nostalgic flavorsImpeccable serviceUnique pickle pizza
Located in a neighborhood in Wilmington, Jay’s Incredible Pizza is a hidden gem that deserves more recognition. The pizza here is a nostalgic experience, reminiscent of childhood memories. The flavors are carefully balanced, the service impeccable, and the atmosphere cozy. Whether you’re a fan of unique toppings like banana peppers and feta cheese or classic options like Hawaiian, Jay’s has something for everyone. While occasional inconsistencies in cooking and service might be a concern, the overall quality of the food makes up for it. Don’t miss out on the opportunity to try the pickle pizza with a garlic ricotta base – it’s truly a delight that you won’t find anywhere else.
Wheelz Pizza of Midtown
9.2/10 (342 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 910-769-2127
Sourdough crustSpecialty pizzasCustomer service
Wheelz Pizza in Midtown is a hidden gem that is sure to satisfy your pizza cravings. The sourdough crust sets them apart from the competition and adds a unique flavor to each slice. The specialty pizzas are a must-try, with options like prosciutto and mozzarella with hot honey and fresh basil, delivering a scrumptious experience. The 3-cheese pizza is another standout, offering a gooey and delicious bite that will keep you coming back for more. The white pizza and buffalo chicken options are also highly recommended by regular customers. While the interior may not be the fanciest, the flavor and quality of the pizza more than make up for it, making Wheelz Pizza a top choice for pizza lovers in town.
Slice of Life Pizzeria & Pub Porters Neck
8.6/10 (484 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 910-686-3882
Delicious Greek saladWelcoming and quick serviceLive music atmosphere
Located in Wilmington, NC, Slice of Life Pizzeria & Pub Porters Neck has quickly become a popular dining spot, offering a mix of delicious food and welcoming service. The lunch special, featuring two slices of pizza and pasta salad, is a standout choice for those looking for a satisfying meal. The Greek salad is a must-try item, perfect for a light and flavorful option. The staff is known for being pleasant and quick with orders, ensuring a positive experience for customers. The restaurant’s atmosphere and live music add to the overall enjoyment of a visit, making it a regular stop for many diners.
Marco’s Pizza
9/10 (57 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 910-888-8338
Perfect pizzasConsistent qualityOutstanding service
Marco’s Pizza in Wilmington has truly nailed it with their fantastic pizzas. The pies are always perfect and delicious, making it the best takeout pizza in town. The crispy thin crust is wonderful, and the quality of the food is consistent every time. The outstanding service provided by John and his crew adds extra value to the overall dining experience, making it a top choice for pizza lovers in the area.